American Integrity Insurance Group 2026 Q3 Earnings Call
Review the key takeaways and the transcript of this earnings call.
- American Integrity Insurance Group reported 3rd quarter 2026 net income of $28.4 million, or $1.44 per diluted share, compared with $13.2 million, or $0.67 per diluted share, a year ago.
- Net premiums earned increased 94.5% to $101.2 million from $52 million, gross premiums written increased 22.7% to $293.3 million from $239.1 million, and gross premiums earned increased 14.9% to $255 million from $221.9 million.
- The combined ratio improved to 70.6% from 78.9%, the net loss ratio improved to 36.6% from 54.1%, and the net underlying loss ratio improved to 31.7% from 49.9%.
- Gross underlying loss ratio was 18.9% compared with 19.3% a year ago, while 3rd quarter catastrophe losses were $5.1 million from severe convective storms compared with none in the prior-year period.
- Annualized return on equity was 29.8%, compared with 17% a year ago, and annualized adjusted return on equity was 29.8%, compared with 18.1% a year ago.
- Shareholders’ equity was $391.2 million at September 30th, up from $337 million at year-end; book value per share was $19.96, up 23.7% year over year and 5.8% since June 30th, 2026.
- The company fully repaid its outstanding surplus note debt during the quarter and ended the period debt-free.
- Voluntary production included approximately 41,000 new policies, 57% more than a year ago; total policies in force increased 18.6% to more than 481,000, and in-force premium increased 17.4% to nearly $1.1 billion.
- Retention improved to 84.9% from 84.4% in the 2nd quarter and 82.8% a year ago.
STOCKNOW INSIGHTS
Continue with outlook and guidance.
Log in to unlock executive comments and Q&A highlights.
Log in for the full summaryStockNow uses AI to translate and summarize earnings calls. Accuracy and completeness are not guaranteed.
Transcript
Preview the first fifteen paragraphs, organized by speaker.
Good morning, and welcome to American Integrity Insurance Group's Q3 2026 earnings conference call. My name is Joel, and I will be your Operator today. All lines are muted. Following the prepared remarks, we will open the call for questions. This call is being recorded. Before we begin, please note that today's remarks may contain forward-looking statements, including comments about the company's outlook, strategy, plans, and expected performance. These statements are based on current expectations and assumptions and are subject to risks and uncertainties that may cause actual results to differ materially. A full discussion of these risks and uncertainties can be found in the company's SEC filings, including its most recently filed annual report on Form 10-K and quarterly reports on Form 10-Q. Management undertakes no obligation to update any forward-looking statements, except to the extent required by law. Furthermore, today's remarks may contain non-GAAP financial measures.
A reconciliation of non-GAAP financial measures to their most comparable GAAP measures is included in the company's quarterly press release and can also be found on its website at www.aii.com. References to American Integrity or the company prior to the consummation of the IPO refer to American Integrity Insurance Group LLC, and after the consummation of the IPO, refer to American Integrity Insurance Group, Inc. With that, I will turn the call over to American Integrity's Founder and Chief Executive Officer, Bob Ritchie.
Please go ahead. Thank you, and good morning, everyone.
Before I discuss our performance, I want to acknowledge the families and the communities affected by Hurricane Isaias. Insurance is a promise made long before it is tested, and following the storm, our team quickly mobilized to the panhandle within 48 hours, meeting our policyholders face-to-face and helping them to begin the claims process and the recovery. I want to thank all of our employees, our agents, our claims partners for doing that important work. Their response reflects what American Integrity was built to do. Turning to our results. This quarter tells an important story about the company we have built over the past 20 years. We are continuing to grow our voluntary business. We are retaining more of the economics that we create, and importantly, we are maintaining the underwriting discipline in a more competitive market.
Our net income has more than doubled year-over-year to $28.4 million in the third quarter. Net premiums earned increased approximately 95% to $101.2 million. Revenue grew 83% year-over-year. Our combined ratio was 70.6%, and our annualized return on equity was 29.8%. More importantly, our results demonstrate how our operating strategy is translating to very strong financial performance. Within our results, the continued growth of our voluntary business is very encouraging. We wrote approximately 41,000 new voluntary policies in this quarter. That is 57% more than the quarter a year ago, and it follows record production in the second quarter. Our total policies in force have increased 18.6% to more than 481,000, and our in-force premium increased 17.4% to nearly $1.1 billion compared to the prior year period. As we continue to grow and build scale, we have maintained our focus on sound risk selection.
We are not pursuing policy count for its own sake. We are pursuing business that we know we can underwrite responsibly and serve well. Let's talk about the couple segments where we are growing. Tri-County is one example of where we see room to grow continuously. We have historically been underrepresented there, yet we now have considerable underwriting experience in the region and longstanding relationships with agents serving it. Improved market conditions have allowed us to expand our appetite and put that experience to work. We believe we can build our presence in Tri-County by being the dependable partner to agents while selecting business that meets our underwriting requirements. The next segment is middle-aged homes. This provides another opportunity, as we talked about, to apply the experience we already have.
This was a core part of our business before Florida's litigation crisis changed the economics of this business, and it prompted us to reduce our participation during the crisis. Not now. With the reform being as strong as it is and an improved operating environment, we are expanding there again. That history matters because we understand the segment, and we have demonstrated a willingness to change our participation as these conditions have changed and improved. Our decisions today must be based on the properties we are underwriting and the returns we expect them to generate. Together, these opportunities give us greater flexibility in where we can write business. We are using that flexibility to build a portfolio that performs over time. Jon Ritchie will discuss the production, the underwriting considerations, and the choices behind that approach.
Our ability to capitalize on these opportunities is directly supported by our independent agency relationships, which are a competitive strength that took us years to earn, and frankly, cannot be replicated simply by deploying capital. In Florida, agents, of course, have choices, and those choices are naturally expanding. We must earn those recommendations every day through a combination of underwriting appetite, consistency, responsiveness, and claim service. These relationships help us identify opportunities, while disciplined execution determines whether we convert them into profitable business. We recently brought together about 50 of our leading agents at what we call our Power of Partnership event. We spent time discussing their businesses, discussing their needs that they see in their communities, and how our evolving appetite can help them serve customers. These discussions are valuable because they connect the opportunities agents see with the business we want to write.
We have spent 20 years building these relationships. Our agents know our people, our agents understand how we underwrite, and our agents know the service they can expect from us. In turn, we understand their businesses. We want that familiarity to translate into confidence when an agent recommends American Integrity to a homeowner. The work behind a relationship continues well after a policy is written, particularly when a customer has a claim. We believe consistent execution across that relationship is how we earn an even greater share of our agent partners' business over time. These relationships are particularly valuable as Florida's property insurance market is becoming healthier and, yes, more competitive. Availability has increased, pricing has moderated, and additional capital has entered, and that's good for homeowners. It also raises the standards for all of us as insurers.
In this environment, results will increasingly depend upon underwriting judgment, distribution relationships, operating efficiency, and the ability to adapt, not merely on the market cycle. We welcome that test. Importantly, our average premium per policy across our portfolio has remained broadly stable year-over-year. That average includes changes in business mix as well as pricing. Growth in tri-county and middle-aged homes is helping to offset appropriate modest rate reductions elsewhere in our book. Our inflation guard adjustment also provides support as rates moderate. We will continue to evaluate pricing against the cost of the risk we are accepting. A portfolio average is very useful context, yet it does not replace that evaluation at the product and market level. We continue to see the benefits of Florida's legislative reforms in lower litigation activity, favorable loss cost trends, and greater insurance availability.
These improvements have helped make additional businesses attracted to write and allowed more carriers to serve homeowners. That is not a bad thing. That is a very responsible, healthy thing in this environment. Preserving a stable operating environment matters to the customers who need coverage and to the capital required to provide it. We will continue to advocate for policies that support a healthy, competitive insurance market. I also want to congratulate Florida's newly elected officials just last week, and we look forward to working with the incoming administration and state leaders. We believe this election outcome supports continuity of these reforms, and we will continue to advocate for a stable, competitive market that serves Florida homeowners. Our opportunity is not limited to one quarter and one part of Florida.
We continue to see room to serve more homeowners in South Florida, in segments of middle-aged homes we know well, and selectively across the Southeast. Yet the defining principle is the same in every market. We will grow where risk-adjusted returns justify the capital we commit. Retaining more of our underwriting economics increases the opportunity for our shareholders and increases our responsibility to manage risk carefully. Jon will now take you through how we are executing on these choices. With that, I will turn the call over to Jon.
Thanks, Bob, and good morning, everyone. I will discuss production across our growth initiatives, underwriting performance, and reinsurance. I will also update you on Hurricane Isaias, which occurred after the third quarter ended. Gross premiums written increased 22.7% to $293.3 million, primarily driven by voluntary business growth. Retention improved to 84.9% from 84.4% in the second quarter and 82.8% a year ago. We are adding new business while retaining a greater share of our existing customers. Both contribute to building our portfolio, and we will continue to evaluate retention alongside pricing and loss performance as competition increases. Florida offers substantial opportunities in market segments where our current participation remains relatively small. Market size helps us identify where to look. Our underwriting requirements determine which opportunities we pursue.
In Tri-County, we wrote approximately 8,000 voluntary new business policies, compared with just over 200 a year ago, and approximately 7,600 in the second quarter. Our sequential growth is encouraging given that the second quarter tends to be our strongest seasonal period for new business. Importantly, Tri-County represents approximately 28% of Florida households and 10% of our Florida policies in force as of September 30. That comparison helps illustrate our relatively small presence and the opportunity for future growth. It does not prescribe our eventual mix. Outside Tri-County, we wrote approximately 8,600 voluntary new business policies on middle-aged homes, compared with fewer than 600 a year ago. This market segment represented about three-quarters of our HO-3 policies in force in 2016, before we reduced our participation during the litigation crisis. That experience gives us a foundation as we expand.
We are applying it to today's property characteristics, pricing, and loss conditions rather than seeking to recreate a historical portfolio mix. As we expand, we look at both the property and what it adds to our overall exposure. Eligibility requirements, roof condition, and inspections help inform selection at the policy level. Geographic concentration and catastrophe exposure also matter when we consider the portfolio. We evaluate those factors together so that an attractive production opportunity remains consistent with our risk appetite. In Georgia, South Carolina, and North Carolina, voluntary new business policies increased 20% year over year. These states accounted for 6.9% of our voluntary in-force premium at quarter end. We see an opportunity to grow this business over time through builder and agency relationships we have already developed. Those partners know American Integrity and our operating approach, giving us a foundation for introducing additional products.
FULL TRANSCRIPT
Continue the full translated transcript in StockNow.
Log in to unlock every statement, the English original, and speaker-by-speaker history.
Log in for the full transcriptCall participants
7 people spoke on this call — only 2 are shown here.
PARTICIPANT LIST
View participant details in StockNow.
Log in to see executives and analysts, their roles, and complete speaking history.
Log in to view all participantsKeep exploring
