Fidelis Insurance Holdings 2026 Q3 Earnings Call
Review the key takeaways and the transcript of this earnings call.
- Pelagos Insurance Capital reported 3rd quarter 2026 operating net income of $83 million, or $1 per diluted common share, and an annualized operating return on average equity of 15.3%.
- Gross premiums written increased 5.3% year over year to $840 million; year-to-date growth was 6.4%, and the company had bound more than $400 million of premium outside of the Fidelis partnership in the first 3 quarters of 2026.
- The combined ratio was 91.5% for the quarter and 92.4% for the first 9 months of 2026; the combined ratio over the last 12 months was 89.6%.
- Catastrophe and large losses were 14.8 points of the quarterly combined ratio, or $116 million, all within insurance, primarily related to the ongoing conflicts in the Black Sea and Middle East.
- The company recorded $5 million of net adverse prior year development in the quarter, or 0.6 points of the combined ratio, primarily in political risk, violence and terror; year-to-date prior year development was favorable by $31 million.
- Net premiums earned were $634 million in insurance and $150 million in reinsurance; insurance exceeded prior guidance, primarily reflecting higher marine war premium written and earned during the quarter.
- Net investment income was $45 million. As of September 30th, 91% of the portfolio was in cash and fixed maturity securities; fixed maturities had an average rating of A+ and a yield of 4.9%, while new money yield was 5.4%.
- The company recognized $27 million of net realized and unrealized investment losses impacting its income statement, primarily driven by rising interest rates on fixed income investments.
- Diluted book value per share, excluding AOCI, was $27.11, up 12% since year-end. The company returned over $400 million to shareholders year to date, including $363 million of common share repurchases.
STOCKNOW INSIGHTS
Continue with outlook and guidance.
Log in to unlock executive comments and Q&A highlights.
Log in for the full summaryStockNow uses AI to translate and summarize earnings calls. Accuracy and completeness are not guaranteed.
Transcript
Preview the first fifteen paragraphs, organized by speaker.
Good morning, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the Pelagos Insurance Capital Third Quarter 2026 Earnings Conference Call. As a reminder, this call is being recorded for replay purposes. Following the conclusion of formal remarks, the management team will host a question-and-answer session, and instructions will be given at that time. With that, I would now like to turn the call over to Miranda Hunter, Group Chief Investor Relations Officer. Ms. Hunter, please go ahead.
Good morning, and welcome to Pelagos Insurance Capital's Third Quarter 2026 Earnings Conference Call. With me today are Dan Burrows, our CEO, Allan Decleir, our CFO, and Jonny Strickle, our Group Managing Director. Before we begin, I'd like to remind everyone that statements made during the call, including the question-and-answer section, will include forward-looking statements. Management's comments regarding expectations, projections, targets, and any future results are based upon current assessments and assumptions and are subject to a number of risks, uncertainties, and emerging information developing over time. It's important to note that actual results may differ materially from those expressed or implied today. Additional information regarding factors shaping these outcomes can be found in our SEC filings, including our earnings press release issued last night. Management will also make reference to certain non-GAAP and proprietary measures of financial performance.
The reconciliations to US GAAP for each non-GAAP financial measure, as well as descriptions of proprietary financial measures, can be found in our earnings press release and financial supplement available on our website at pelagosinsurancecapital.com. With that, I'll turn the call over to Dan.
Thanks, Miranda. Good morning, everyone, and thank you for joining us today. We delivered another successful quarter, reflecting the strength of our capital allocator model with a 15.3% annualized operating ROAE. As I reflect on this strong performance, I want to highlight once again the three key points that stand out as our defining attributes of our business. First, we delivered a 5.3% increase in gross premiums written this quarter, in line with our expectations provided on the last call, as we continue to find attractive opportunities to deploy capital. Our ability to respond quickly to evolving market conditions and dynamically allocate capital across our diverse and growing network of underwriting partners enables us to grow in lines with favorable risk-adjusted returns.
With our expanding network of underwriting partners, we have already bound more than $400 million of premium outside of The Fidelis Partnership in the first three quarters of 2026. This distribution network has broadened our access to attractive risks in both existing and new lines and is the primary driver of our 6.4% year-to-date growth. As you will hear today, we are positioned to accelerate this trajectory. Second, our portfolio continues to deliver attractive returns. Against the backdrop of heightened loss activity amid ongoing global geopolitical conflicts, we delivered a combined ratio of 91.5% in the third quarter and 89.6% over the last 12 months. Our 15.3% annualized operating ROAE in the quarter is a clear reflection of our successful ability to deploy capital across multiple avenues to create shareholder value. Third, alongside strong growth, we extended our track record of returning excess capital to shareholders.
During the quarter, we returned $95 million to shareholders, including repurchasing $83 million of common shares. This included $35 million in a privately negotiated transaction with Pine Brook. Last week, we announced another meaningful expansion of our capital management initiatives with the replenishment of our common share repurchase authorization to $400 million and an increase to our quarterly dividends to $0.22 per share. Taken together, these three points reflect the very core of our strategy: driving growth, deploying capital to opportunities offering the most attractive returns, and returning capital to shareholders.
In fact, there is no better reflection of the success of our capital allocator model to date than the balance we have achieved between capital returns and profitable underwriting, adding $2.23 to our book value per share through share repurchases since the inception of the program in 2024, while delivering premium growth of 40% over the same period. Turning to performance across each of our segments. Within insurance, we delivered 13% growth in gross premiums written in the third quarter, driven by marine war and continued diversification into lower volatility lines within our other insurance line of business. Similar to the trends we shared last quarter, marine war, Political Risk, and Political Violence all experienced strong demand driven by ongoing geopolitical tensions, including in the Middle East conflict, where there has been a significant and prolonged escalation of marine war breach underwriting activity.
The situation remains fluid, and we maintained our agile approach, executing in the open market and actively managing our portfolio at the individual risk level. Within marine war, opportunities arose in the back half of the quarter that aligned with our risk appetite. We were able to respond quickly to support our clients while maintaining our discipline and focus on long-term profitability. Asset-backed finance and portfolio credit remains an important part of our portfolio as we continue to see demand for our bespoke transaction structures. Our focus is on risk-adjusted returns and counterparty quality, and we continue to see a strong pipeline supported by new transactions from returning clients and the broadening of participation from financial institutions. In property, we continue to see rate adequacy with terms and conditions holding steady.
As a market leader, we benefit from greater differentiation and are well-positioned to capitalize on opportunities across the broader market, given our expertise, line size, and unique access points. We maintained our disciplined approach, walking away from risks that did not meet our return hurdles. Turning to reinsurance, property reinsurance gross premiums written declined year-over-year, largely due to the restructuring of one client's outwards program. Excluding this impact, our premiums would have been broadly flat. We expect some of that premium to return through a different program early next year. We are pleased with the results of the July renewal season. While property reinsurance remains competitive, we've been able to mitigate pricing pressure by shifting capacity towards quota share deals over excess of loss, leaning into the cross-selling initiatives, and leveraging our deep client relationships.
We are also benefiting from improved outwards reinsurance instruments, which are enhancing margins and returns. Our scale and differentiated view of risk continue to enable us to identify opportunities without chasing premium at the expense of returns. Before I hand it over to Allan to discuss our third quarter results in more detail, I'd like to take a moment to highlight how our capital allocation model uniquely positions us in this market. Our business is built around three key strengths: expertise, optionality, and agility. Together, they allow us to respond to changing market conditions, access a broader range of opportunities, and allocate capital where we see the most attractive returns. No single underwriting team sees every opportunity. By partnering with multiple leading underwriting teams, each with distinct access, relationships, expertise, and distribution channels, we see a broader range of opportunities than any individual partner alone.
That allows us to compare, select, and allocate capital to the risks that offer the most attractive returns, creating a stronger and more diversified portfolio. We have a strong pipeline from our expanding underwriting partner network, which we expect to remain a core driver of our growth. That is how we intend to scale, not by doing more of everything, but by being increasingly selective, effective, and coordinated in how we deploy capital. It's a model built to adapt through the cycle and capitalize on opportunities as they emerge, and it gives us confidence in our ability to accelerate top-line growth, deliver our through-the-cycle ROAE target of 13%-15%, and create lasting value for shareholders. With that, I'll turn the call over to Allan.
Thanks, Dan. We delivered operating net income of $83 million, or $1 per diluted common share in the third quarter, generating an annualized operating return on average equity of 15.3%. Our diluted book value per share, excluding AOCI, was $27.11, increasing 12% since year-end. Taking a look at our quarterly results. We grew our gross premiums written by 5.3% versus the same quarter last year to $840 million. The growth in our insurance segment was primarily driven by our marine and other insurance lines of business as we continued to see attractive opportunities in marine war and further diversified into lower volatility lines. In reinsurance, the reduction in the quarter primarily related to the restructuring of one of our clients' programs. Excluding that timing impact, premiums would have been broadly flat.
Our net premiums earned in insurance were $634 million, ahead of the guidance we gave last quarter, primarily reflecting higher marine war premium written and earned during the quarter. In reinsurance, net premiums earned were within our expectations at $150 million. Looking to the fourth quarter, we expect net earned premiums to be $550 million-$600 million in insurance and $85 million-$105 million in reinsurance. Our combined ratio was 91.5% for the quarter and 92.4% for the first nine months of 2026. I will now break down the components of our combined ratio in more detail. For the quarter, our catastrophe and large losses were 14.8 points of the combined ratio, or $116 million, all within our insurance segment.
These losses were primarily related to losses from the ongoing conflicts in the Black Sea and Middle East, with the Black Sea losses related to business written before the recent re-escalation in the region. During the quarter, our attritional loss ratio was 29.5 points of the combined ratio. Most of our attritional loss originates from the insurance segment, which year-to-date is running at 30.8 points and in line with our long-term expectations for this segment. Some of the opportunities we have seen more recently in our insurance segment are lower volatility, and those typically come with low or no catastrophe and large loss ratio, but a higher attritional loss ratio. As our business mix changes and evolves over time, the split between attritional and cat and large loss will evolve with it. As we have indicated previously, we expect an overall loss ratio in the mid-40s.
We recognized $5 million of net adverse prior year development in the quarter, or a 0.6 point impact on the combined ratio. This was primarily related to our political risk, violence, and terror line of business, and was largely offset by better-than-expected loss emergence in multiple lines of business in our insurance segment, and continued favorable development in our reinsurance segment. As noted previously, given our business mix, most of our prior year development tends to emerge during the first half of the year. Year-to-date, we have favorable development of $31 million. Turning to expenses, policy acquisition expenses were 30.4 points of the combined ratio for the third quarter, consistent with 29.9 points in the prior year period. Policy acquisition expenses to TFP were 12.4 points of the combined ratio in the quarter, compared to 14.5 points in the prior year period.
FULL TRANSCRIPT
Continue the full translated transcript in StockNow.
Log in to unlock every statement, the English original, and speaker-by-speaker history.
Log in for the full transcriptCall participants
9 people spoke on this call — only 2 are shown here.
PARTICIPANT LIST
View participant details in StockNow.
Log in to see executives and analysts, their roles, and complete speaking history.
Log in to view all participantsKeep exploring
