CitigroupC
Recorded

Citigroup Citi’s 15th Annual FinTech Conference

Review the key takeaways and the transcript of this earnings call.

PeriodFY 0Duration34 minParticipants2

Transcript

Preview the first fifteen paragraphs, organized by speaker.

Bryan KeaneHead of North America Payments Processors and IT Services Research

We are excited to have our next speaker. I'm Bryan Keane, of course, and it's about the 25th time I've said I'd cover fintech here for Citi Research. We're excited to have my Citi colleague, Pam Habner, who is the head of U.S. Cards. We have a great list of questions here for Pam to go through and talk a little bit about what we're doing in the cards business at Citi. First off, really excited to have you here, Pam.

Pam HabnerHead of U.S. Consumer Cards

Thanks for coming. Thank you so much.

Pam HabnerHead of U.S. Consumer Cards

I'm delighted to be here.

Bryan KeaneHead of North America Payments Processors and IT Services Research

Maybe you could just talk a little bit to this audience that might not know you as well. You can walk us through a little bit about your background and what led you to your current role of U.S. Consumer Cards business at Citi.

Pam HabnerHead of U.S. Consumer Cards

Sure. I started off my career as a consultant. I worked at Bain & Company, and I always say we're recovering consultants. We never quite give that up. Then I decided that I really wanted to pursue a career in general management, so I joined American Express, where I worked for about 20 years in almost every role you can imagine on the card issuing side, not the network side. A little bit in the commercial area, but mostly on the consumer side, managing products and acquisitions and all kinds of interesting things. I did do a dot-com detour, so I left Amex for three years, and I worked at two ad tech startups. One was called LinkShare, the first affiliate marketing company, and the other was DoubleClick, the first ad serving company. So I have a little bit of fintech in my background.

Pam HabnerHead of U.S. Consumer Cards

I went back to American Express, and then after many years, I moved over to JP Morgan. There, I worked in the credit card business for a couple of years, leading the proprietary products, launching Sapphire Reserve and a whole bunch of other things, and then also led the retail branch banking and wealth management team. So that was a very different job over in the retail bank and wealth side. That's when I got introduced to Citi and the amazing leadership team at Citi. I met Jane, Anand Selva, and a bunch of other folks. I never thought I was going to leave JP Morgan, but I got so inspired by being part of the next chapter of this great company that I joined Citi in the summer of 2020, right in the midst of the pandemic.

Pam HabnerHead of U.S. Consumer Cards

We've been on a journey ever since then to obviously transform the company and in the card business, to transform the business, and just excited this year to bring the two different card businesses at Citi, what was called, we call it legacy Branded Cards and Citi Retail Services, into one unified franchise that is now one of the five main businesses at Citi.

Bryan KeaneHead of North America Payments Processors and IT Services Research

All right, that was awesome. I was thinking maybe we even start higher level up because we get, at Citi, such a good look at the health of the U.S. consumer. Maybe you could just talk about what you're seeing in activity levels and what the outlook might be for the holiday season, given your view on the consumer.

Pam HabnerHead of U.S. Consumer Cards

Yeah. So I would say despite a very uncertain macroeconomic and geopolitical environment, the U.S. consumer remains incredibly resilient. We're seeing very strong consumer spending. In third quarter, we saw spending up 11%. We see loans at a strong level as well, 6%. So the consumer is shopping, is borrowing, but in a very disciplined way. So we feel very positive about our base. Now, as a reminder, Citi operates in largely the prime segment. 86% of our customers are FICO 660 or greater, so we're not fully reflective of all elements of the U.S. consumer, but the place that we play in the prime space remains very strong. We do see higher spending in the higher FICO segments. That's always been the case, but we see pretty strong growth at every FICO level, every band.

Pam HabnerHead of U.S. Consumer Cards

People often ask me, "Do we see this K-shaped phenomenon persisting?" The answer is not as much so. We are kind of referring it to a soft K or a K kind of receding. We see definitely higher spend in the higher bands, but equal spending throughout. The broader picture, obviously, we spend a lot of time looking at macroeconomic variables. For the credit card business and for the U.S. consumer, we watch very closely unemployment. Unemployment has been pretty low. We just saw a pretty good jobs report, so we are at about 4.1%, and we expect that to largely persist. We watch very closely inflation in relation to wage growth. In recent periods, inflation has been in about 3.5%, 3.4%, but wage growth has been a bit higher.

Pam HabnerHead of U.S. Consumer Cards

If that were to shift, we might be a bit concerned, especially in an environment where consumer savings are not as strong as we would like them to be. But generally, the consumer is resilient. We expect that to continue. We talk to lots of experts, and there is a general feeling that the holiday season will be strong, kind of think mid-single digit growth in spending, around 5%. We will see how that plays out, but that is what we are generally seeing. The one thing that we do know, however, is that consumer sentiment is slightly different than consumer behavior. Consumer sentiment has been low. It stayed low. If you look at any of the surveys coming out of the midterms, you see the vast majority of U.S. consumers do not feel optimistic. They feel relatively pessimistic about the future and how their financials will look a year from now.

Pam HabnerHead of U.S. Consumer Cards

We watch that closely as well. There is a bit of the AI anxiety that is feeding into that phenomenon. But for quite some time, consumer sentiment has not matched actual consumer behavior.

Bryan KeaneHead of North America Payments Processors and IT Services Research

I was going to ask about that because that seems unusual to me. Does it usually match, the sentiment usually matches the behavior? Because behavior, we have been waiting for this recession for five years. That has never happened. The consumer has been more melancholy about the economy, but continues to spend really well.

Pam HabnerHead of U.S. Consumer Cards

I would say, I've been in the credit card space for many years, and I would say for most of that time, consumer sentiment tracks consumer behavior. Over the past year or so, that has just not been true.

Pam HabnerHead of U.S. Consumer Cards

Yeah. I don't know that I can fully explain it.

FULL TRANSCRIPT

Continue the full translated transcript in StockNow.

Access every statement, the English original, and speaker-by-speaker history with StockNow Pro.

View the full transcript with Pro

Other earnings calls that day

View calls from this day